State Comparison

New York vs South Dakota LLC

Side-by-side comparison of forming an LLC in New York vs South Dakota — fees, processing times, taxes, and decision factors to help you choose the right state for your business.

New York

Filing fee$200

Processing7–15 days

Annual report$9

State income tax4%-10.9% state + NYC 3.876%

Biennial Statement of Information, $9

South Dakota

Filing fee$150

Processing5–10 days

Annual report$50

State income taxVaries by personal bracket

See state Secretary of State for specifics

Lower state fees:

South Dakota — $200 total 1st-year state fees

Excludes franchise tax, registered agent, and other compliance costs

Pros and Cons

New York (NY)

Pros

Largest economy in the country with access to Wall Street capital
Strong B2B ecosystem
Major global city for many industries

Cons

Publication requirement: 6 weeks in 2 newspapers ($500-$2,000 depending on county)
NYC Unincorporated Business Tax (UBT) above $100K
High state income tax (4%-10.9% + NYC 3.876%)
Costly for small businesses at formation

South Dakota (SD)

Pros

Established LLC statute
Pass-through taxation at federal level
No unusual restrictions on LLC ownership

Cons

Foreign qualification may be needed if operating elsewhere
Annual state compliance required to maintain good standing

Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature	New York	South Dakota
LLC filing fee	$200	$150
Corporation filing fee	$125	$150
Annual report fee	$9	$50
Processing time	7–15 days	5–10 days
State income tax	4%-10.9% state + NYC 3.876%	Varies by personal bracket
Franchise / entity tax	Biennial Statement of Information, $9	See state Secretary of State for specifics
Popular formation state?	Yes	No

Which Should You Choose?

Choose New York if...

• Publication requirement alone can cost $2,000+ in NYC

• Better to form in home state and foreign qualify if needed

• You live or operate primarily in New York — forming locally avoids foreign qualification costs and compliance in multiple states.

Choose South Dakota if...

• Check state-specific requirements for your industry and structure

• You live or operate primarily in South Dakota — forming locally avoids foreign qualification costs and compliance in multiple states.

FAQ

Is it cheaper to form an LLC in New York or South Dakota?

New York charges $200 filing + $9 annual report. South Dakota charges $150 filing + $50 annual report. South Dakota is the cheaper option on state fees alone, though franchise tax and other compliance costs also matter.

Should I form my LLC in New York or South Dakota?

For most businesses, form in the state where you actually operate. New York (4%-10.9% state + NYC 3.876% state income tax) and South Dakota (Varies by personal bracket state income tax) each have their specific characteristics. If you physically operate in one of these states, form there. Forming in New York while operating in South Dakota (or vice versa) means paying fees in both states.

Can I form my LLC in New York and operate in South Dakota?

Yes, but you'll need to "foreign qualify" in South Dakota, which means paying a registration fee in South Dakota plus ongoing compliance in both states. You'll also typically owe South Dakota state taxes on income earned there regardless of where the LLC is formed. Forming in a single state (usually your home state) is typically cleaner and cheaper for small businesses.

What are the annual costs for an LLC in New York vs South Dakota?

New York: Biennial Statement of Information, $9 — plus $100-$300/yr for a registered agent. South Dakota: See state Secretary of State for specifics — plus $100-$300/yr for a registered agent. Budget an additional $500-$2,000/yr for accounting, bookkeeping, and business license renewals regardless of state.

Which state has better asset protection — New York or South Dakota?

Asset protection varies by state statute. States like Wyoming, Nevada, and Delaware have the strongest charging-order-exclusive doctrines for LLC members. New York and South Dakota both offer LLC liability protection, but consult an attorney for state-specific asset protection planning if you have significant personal assets to shield.

New York resources

South Dakota resources

Ready to form your LLC?

FormifyAI files your Articles of Organization in any US state. EIN, operating agreement, BOI report, and registered agent included. Starting at $39/month with annual billing.

Start your LLC Interactive state comparison tool

Back to all states

Pros and Cons

New York (NY)

Pros

Largest economy in the country with access to Wall Street capital
Strong B2B ecosystem
Major global city for many industries

Cons

Publication requirement: 6 weeks in 2 newspapers ($500-$2,000 depending on county)
NYC Unincorporated Business Tax (UBT) above $100K
High state income tax (4%-10.9% + NYC 3.876%)
Costly for small businesses at formation

South Dakota (SD)

Pros

Established LLC statute
Pass-through taxation at federal level
No unusual restrictions on LLC ownership

Cons

Foreign qualification may be needed if operating elsewhere
Annual state compliance required to maintain good standing

Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature	New York	South Dakota
LLC filing fee	$200	$150
Corporation filing fee	$125	$150
Annual report fee	$9	$50
Processing time	7–15 days	5–10 days
State income tax	4%-10.9% state + NYC 3.876%	Varies by personal bracket
Franchise / entity tax	Biennial Statement of Information, $9	See state Secretary of State for specifics
Popular formation state?	Yes	No

Which Should You Choose?

Choose New York if...

• Publication requirement alone can cost $2,000+ in NYC

• Better to form in home state and foreign qualify if needed

• You live or operate primarily in New York — forming locally avoids foreign qualification costs and compliance in multiple states.

Choose South Dakota if...

• Check state-specific requirements for your industry and structure

• You live or operate primarily in South Dakota — forming locally avoids foreign qualification costs and compliance in multiple states.